“Mind you, I’ve been here during the bad times too. One year we came second.” (Bob Paisley)
It would not be unreasonable to ask why, having won six league titles and three European Cups with Liverpool, Bob Paisley is only twelfth in our list of the finest managers of all time. A name synonymous with the Merseyside club, Paisley made over 250 appearances for The Reds between 1939 and 1954 before retiring from the playing staff to become a physiotherapist at Anfield, only to be appointed manager in 1974.
The reason why Paisley is only twelfth is, not to detract from his incredible achievements, because the team that he enjoyed such success with was not entirely “his” team – Liverpool had been driven into a position to succeed by the work of his predecessor, Bill Shankly. That said, although Paisley may not have built the Liverpool team that dominated both England and Europe in the 1970s, few managers have been able to match the relentless success which Paisley brought about at club level.
Taking over in the wake of Shankly’s unexpected and shocking resignation, Liverpool looked to Paisley – a member of Shankly’s famous “Boot Room” – for continuity and a steady hand during what could have been a difficult transitional time for the club. With no previous managerial experience, his first season in charge – the 1974/75 campaign – saw Liverpool finish second to Dave Mackay’s Derby County in the First Division, but it wasn’t to be long before Paisley began to fill the Anfield trophy cabinet with a veritable procession of silverware.
The 1975/76 season was a successful one on Merseyside, Liverpool winning their first title for three years thanks to the goals of John Toshack and Kevin Keegan and starting a run which would lead to an incredible six titles in nine years. Throughout that time Paisley turned the Anfield club into a true sporting dynasty and oversaw the best years of a team that included such famous names as Emlyn Hughes, Terry McDermott, Alan Hansen, Ray Clemence and Kenny Dalglish. This was the generation that defined Liverpool Football Club, and Bob Paisley was the man subtly pulling the strings in the background.
Although Paisley’s triumphs on the domestic front were hugely impressive, it was to be on the European stage that the Sunderland-born manager was to mark himself out as one of the finest coaches the game has ever seen. Throughout the late 1970s and early 80s his Liverpool side dominated the European Cup, winning the competition in 1977, 1978 and 1981 (overcoming Borussia Mönchengladbach, Club Brugge and Real Madrid in the respective finals) as well as claiming the 1976 UEFA Cup.
It was a run of success unparalleled by any British club before or since and Paisley, who rarely gets assigned the great credit he deserves, should be far more widely lauded for attained during his time at Anfield.
He may not have been the most imaginative of tacticians in terms of the shape of his teams – Paisley was very much an advocate of the traditional 4-4-2 – but he was revered as an expert in applying the pass-and-move ethos which was at the heart of Liverpool’s sustained run of success. Added to that, Paisley was by all accounts an astute man-manager, something which was reflected in Liverpool’s astonishing run of 85 games unbeaten at home between 1978 and 1981. If not a particularly eloquent man, Paisley was said to be astute in the subtle way in which he motivated his players, tactical in his use of criticism in order to get his charges fired up to prove him wrong.
He may not have been the most modern of managers in terms of his methods, but what he did worked to great effect and it would seem from some reports that he had a far more analytical eye for the game than he liked to let on. Indeed, his signing of Kenny Dalglish in 1977 proved that he was an excellent judge of a player and was a master at finding the right personnel to fit his system.
Retiring in 1983 as a one-club man, Paisley became a board member and served the club until his death in 1996. As I said at the top of the profile, the Anfield legend may not be regarded as the most important or formative manager in Liverpool’s history, but he was unquestionably the man who took the club to the peak of its powers. For the astonishing success he achieved in a relatively short space of time, Bob Paisley should forever be considered one of the greatest managers in the history of both British and European football.






My respect for the man has been enhanced by this piece. Good read.
6 titles in 9 years was totally unprecedented in English football history. In addition 3 European Cups in 9 years but number 4 (in the season after he retired) was with Paisley’s assembled team bar Phil Neal so Paisley proved able to build a team who were European Champions.
Paisley was the greatest!
Six titles in nine years, in an era that saw a whole host of sides believing in title glory, says an awful lot about Bob as a manager.
His achievements should never rendered nor forgotten.
“the team that he enjoyed such success with was not entirely “his” team – Liverpool had been driven into a position to succeed by the work of his predecessor, Bill Shankly.”
Totally disagree with this statement. Paisley was as much behind building Liverpool behind the scenes as Shankly was. It is often said that he was the tactician and the man who meticulously researched opposition teams.
The majority when Liverpool won their first European Cup in 1977 were Paisley’s signings. He actually famously took apart Shankly’s team when he took over which saw a lot of criticism come his way at the time, selling Kevin Keegan which a lot of people thought was ridiculous at the time, he then went and replaced him with some Scot named Dalglish.
Not to mention Shankly didn’t actually build the club at all. When Shankly took over, although Liverpool were in the Second Division, they were still one of the biggest clubs in the country getting attendences that the majority of the First Division couldn’t match and only Arsenal had won more league titles than Liverpool up to that point. And they were hardly amazing under Shankly either. They won a couple of league titles and that was it. Also, why do people say “if Shankly hadn’t built Liverpool, they wouldn’t have won everything they did under Paisley” as if it should add to his reputation? What does that have to with Shankly? If the manager following him had been shit they wouldn’t have won everything they did either.
Also, look at Shankly’s record before Liverpool when he didn’t have the man who would go on to become the arguably most proflific manager in English football: it is absolutely abysmal with about 5 different clubs. He relegated Huddersfield, turned Grimsby from promotion chasers to relegation battlers and stood still everywhere else he went. Then in the only successful job he ever did he had one of the most prolific managers the world has ever seen in his backroom staff who he famously discussed football with endlessly in his “boot room.” Coincidence? I think not.
Honestly, this idea that “Shankly built the house and Paisley built the roof” is just inaccurate for a whole heap of reasons. It should be more like “Shankly and Paisley designed the house together, then Paisley built it.”
I honestly believe Shankly gets vastly overrated by his personality and his endless quotes and going on about how working class he was and Bob Paisley gets underrated for being a shy, retiring man. If their personalities were reversed, Paisley would have his rightful placement in the top 5 of this list and Shankly would have been a long forgotten footnote in English football.
dalglish and ian rush were brougth by paisely…it was no way shankly made team..
Excellently put, Mike. I’ve always been perplexed at the praise heaped on Shankly with Paisley at times almost being a footnote. Certainly needs further dissection and discussion.
This is, however, an excellent article inkeeping with the rest of the Top 20 managers series and I am intrigued as to who the Equaliser will put in the top 10 considering the 10 we have already put on the board.
Bob Paisley is without doubt the greatest manager that English football has ever seen and ever will see.
Sir Alex Ferguson is (and always will be) a mere novice in comparision.
The only manager that even approaches Bob Paisley (apart from Shanks) is Brian Clough because he did it on a shoestring budget.
[...] “The Boot Room“, as it became known, was where the likes of Shankly, Joe Fagan and Bob Paisley would sit and discuss tactics and ideas, formulating the strategies which would eventually see [...]
Paisley´s team?
1977 line up against M´gladbach (date signed)
http://www.lfchistory.net/viewgame.asp?game_id=979
1 Ray Clemence (jun 67)
2 Phil Neal (oct 74)
3 Joey Jones (jul 75)
4 Tommy Smith (apr 62)
5 Ray Kennedy (jul 74 – Shanks retirement day)
6 Emlyn Hughes (feb 67)
7 Kevin Keegan (may 71)
8 Jimmy Case (may 73)
9 Steve Heighway (may 70)
10 Ian Callaghan (mar 60)
11 Terry McDermott (nov 74)
Subs
12 David Fairclough (jan 74)
13 Peter McDonnell (jul 74)
14 David Johnson (aug 76)
15 Alan Waddle (june 73)
16 Alec Lindsay (mar 69)
Oh, and Mike.
“And they were hardly amazing under Shankly either. They won a couple of league titles and that was it.”
Bit harsh?
Quite frankly, despite his haul of trophies, if it were my list, Paisley wouldn’t figure at all. He was a good manager, but hardly a great, having inherited an already great team built up largely by Shankley, as the previous post shows.
Granted, he did buy some top-class players, but wouldn’t have had the money to do so, were it not for Shankley. Selling the unsettled greedy Keegan and using the money to buy the already proven Dalgish (Scotland’s most prolific goalscorer) was hardly a work of genius, just common sense.
Perhaps the nearest Paisley came to genius was converting the half-decent ex-Arsenal forward Ray Kennedy to an excellent defender.
As for the comparisons between Shankley/Paisley and Clough/Taylor saying Clough achieved very little after falling out with Taylor. That’s still a damn sight more than Taylor achieved on his own.